Saturday, 8 July 2017

The school research lead and management gurus: John Kotter - what's the evidence for his eight steps in leading change

A few weeks ago I wrote about the need for school leaders to be appropriately critical of the work of educational and management 'gurus'.   One such guru is John Kotter, whose name is often found in lists of world's leading management thinkers.  Indeed,  Kotter's influence is not limited to business - with the  leading educationalist @Andy_Buck - author of the popular book - Leadership Matters  recently tweeting 'when it comes to change, you can't beat  Kotter'.   



So with that in mind, I thought it might be useful to see whether there's any empirical evidence to support Kotter's most well-known model - the eight step process for leading change.  In doing so, we will draw upon the work of (Appelbaum, Habashy, Malo, & Shafiq, 2012) who looked at fifteen years of literature of change management in order to see whether there is evidence to support Kotter's change management model.

First published in 1995 in the Harvard Business Review and subsequently in 1996 as a book - Leading Change - Kotter outlines an eight stage process for change management
  1. Establish a sense of urgency about the need to achieve change 
  2. Create a guiding coalition
  3. Develop a vision and strategy
  4. Communicate the change vision
  5. Empower broad-based actions
  6. Generate short-term wins
  7. Consolidate gains and produce more change
  8. Anchor new approaches in the corporate culture
However, as Applebaum et al note - Leading Change - is based on Kotter's own personal research and business experience, with there being no supporting footnotes, references or bibliography.  That said, Applebaum et al review of the change management literature found support for most of the steps, although no research studies were found covering all eight steps included in model. As such Applebaum et al note that  Kotter’s change management model appears gain its popularity from its' apparent practicality rather than a robust evidence base confirming success in the use of the model.

Nevertheless,  Applebaum et al go onto argue that Kotter's model might not be appropriate for all types of change and they go onto identify a number of limitations of the model.

A rigid approach - Kotter argues that the eight steps should be followed in sequence and that extended overlapping of the steps will compromise success, implying steps are requisite of one another .... (and) where such prescriptions run counters to the organization's culture they will be either ignored or be ineffective 

Some steps are not relevant in some contexts - Some transformations do require not are able to go through certain steps .... examples could include changes with a needs for a great deal of secrecy, where Steps 1 and 4, will be significantly undermined.

Dealing with difficulties during change management ... Companies implementing changes face many difficulties ... but the model is insufficiently detailed to help in all scenarios

Difficulties os studying change management project - Studying changes management projects is inherently difficult, due to their sheer complexity (p775 -6)

The implication for you as a school-leader

That said, Applebaum et al argue that  Kotter's change management model remains a recommendable reference as the model a useful checklist for leaders and managers who wish to bring about change.  As such school leaders and MAT CEOs who wish to bring about change in their schools and/or academy chains might find Kotter's eight steps a 'good-bet'.  However, that's all it is - a good-bet - which increases the chance of, but does not guarantee successful change.  Indeed, school leaders and MAT CEOs who wish to increase further their chances of success, should take into account the individual culture of the school/MAT so the change process is aligned with how things work in your context.

References

Appelbaum, S. H., Habashy, S., Malo, J.-L., & Shafiq, H. (2012). Back to the future: revisiting Kotter's 1996 change model. Journal of Management Development, 31(8), 764-782.

Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change: Harvard Business Press.



28 comments:

  1. I truly expected to write a quick comment remembering the right content to offer on account of you for these surprising information you are putting on your site. You are persistently driving an explosive work. I should state you have created mind blowing article. day school

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good information to know and right to the point on career in corporate. Thanks for this well written post related to search jobs , i’ll follow up for more updates if you keep posting them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good information to know and right to the point on career. Thanks for this well written post related to search jobs , i’ll follow up for more updates if you keep posting them.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I feel the issue of body language is not being familiarized with people as much as it should be in this region, I dont know maybe there are things that I dont know about taking place, but in general i feel people lack information and awareness about it.. I am happy to hear that there is executive leadership training at the institute mentioned in the article

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel the issue of body language is not being familiarized with people as much as it should be in this region, I dont know maybe there are things that I dont know about taking place, but in general i feel people lack information and awareness about it.. I am happy to hear that there ranking purpose <a href="wwww.datesheet-nic.in>Datesheet board 2018</a>

    ReplyDelete
  6. I feel the issue of body language is not being familiarized with people as much as it should be in this region, I dont know maybe there are things that I dont know about taking place, but in general i feel people lack information and awareness about it.. I am happy to hear that there ranking purpose <a href="wwww.datesheet-nic.in>Datesheet</a>

    ReplyDelete
  7. Most Trusted Assignment Helpsince 2001. We are aware of all assignments. Assignment Help exactly according to guidelines|guaranteed grades

    ReplyDelete
  8. This blog is really informative for us. I have read your whole blog you have mentioned points deeply. Thanks for write this kind of informative blog.smart home automation

    ReplyDelete
  9. Pleasure to come here all the time, wonderful post. hp printer setup

    ReplyDelete
  10. this article gives me mellow in which I can take away at the truth. this is top notch one and offers inside and out measurements. much obliged to you for this top notch article.
    gemstone online

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for sharing valuable content, this is what I need to know. Thank you once again, it's very interesting. I wish you all the best for your next blog in future.Buy Weed Online

    ReplyDelete
  12. Well as your other previous post this one also very informative and remarkable for users specially new comer. I must say good work appreciate it!
    Technical Support for canon Printers

    ReplyDelete
  13. It is an amazing post, i found you randomly over the internet i feel so good! Keep writing waiting your new post.
    Canon Printer Support

    ReplyDelete
  14. You always write new and unique informative blog, like other blogs this blog is also remarkable. You presented so well, you did a great job. keep writing and inspiring us.
    Adobe Technical Support Number

    ReplyDelete
  15. I feel so fortunate to come to your blog to be a new member on your blog it's superb for me I generally get such huge numbers of new thing over your blog. I hope i will get more valuable knowledge in your blogs.trend micro support phone number

    ReplyDelete
  16. I feel so fortunate to come to your blog to be a new member on your blog it's superb for me I generally get such huge numbers of new thing over your blog. I hope i will get more valuable knowledge in your blogs.http://Bigpondemails.com/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Garmin is the known organization for creating items in the classes of expert aeronautics, marine gadgets that goes for making utilization of GPS for simple route, customer items. Its claim to fame in making gadgets, for example, hand-held GPS units getting very prominent as Garmin GPS resembles authentic companion for the individuals who explore the exact route in obscure city or nation. This route gadget helps in exploring from one source to the correct goal.

    Visit: https://www.csutomerserve24.com/
    Call For Garmin Issues: 1-866-992-8099

    ReplyDelete
  18. Telstra e-mail, currently rebranded as Telstra is a membership based email provider that promises customizable performances. Yet in presenting a lot of new attributes, new mistakes have arised. Open of the most obtuse of these malfunctions is the error code 550.
    Telstra Technical Support phone Number

    ReplyDelete
  19. Be it printing related or driver download related or some other issue with your Brother printer, brother-supports.com is the correct goal to set them up. We are a confided in name in this space known for conveying moment investigating steps or determination for the errors you look with your new or as of now utilizing Brother printer. To associate with one of our specialists, get your phone and dial our Brother toll-free number 1-800-218-9750. We will never disappoint you.
    Brother Printer Support
    Brother Printer Phone Support
    Brother Printer Customer Service Number
    Brother Printer Toll-Free Number

    ReplyDelete
  20. Our digital strategists dive into your business analytics to put together strategies for reaching your business goals.
    When you have a great story about how your product or service was built to change lives, share it. online digital marketing

    ReplyDelete
  21. Advanced promoting is the showcasing of items or administrations utilizing computerized innovations, essentially on the Internet, yet additionally including cell phones, show publicizing, and some other computerized medium.https://express.yudu.com/profile/index#edit-details

    ReplyDelete
  22. Welcome to Adobe users For technical issues, You can try Adobe support phone number 1-855-272-4602 anytime you need help.

    Adobe Technical Support Phone Number
    Adobe Customer Service Number
    Adobe Support Number
    Adobe Phone Number

    ReplyDelete
  23. The best things about Marketing Land is that it features daily breaking news stories about all aspects of the digital marketing industry so you can get most of your digital marketing news from the one place.
    online marketing company

    ReplyDelete
  24. Setup Your Account In New Device | Bigpond Email Support 1-800-980-183
    By getting Bigpond Email Support, you can optimize your Bigpond account according to your need. Dial toll-free number 1-800-980-183 and our officials will assist you to overcome email account issues.
    • Obtain fast service from tech master to deal with set-up procedure of email account
    • Recover deleted and corrupted emails in a minute by getting a complete support of tech team
    To get more tech help, you can visit the site: -http://bigpond.australiasupportemail.com/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi this is Adam Hoghe from Brisbane Australia .I appreciate your thinking about this work You are doing a great job keep. We provide support for Bigpond email in Australia. You just dial 1800-980-183 and explain the issue we solve that at minimal time. For more details visit us now http://bigpond.australiasupportemail.com/.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Microsoft Office is one of the easy and the most reliable software. If you are looking for any technical support for Microsoft products. Feel free to contact Microsoft support phone number 1-800-279-1380 24*7.

    Microsoft Support Phone Number
    Microsoft Support Number
    Microsoft Phone number

    ReplyDelete
  27. Web development company +91-8377079156
    Thanks for sharing the great informative article with excellent idea I really enjoyed your article Thanks for sharing this and keep writing. Internet growth is everything associated with the creation of a website.
    For more visit to our website http://www.cosmocratwebsolutions.com/

    ReplyDelete