Monday, 30 March 2015

We need to talk about researchEDthics - School Research Leads and Ethical Research and Evidence-Based School Cultures

This post was first published in March 2015

At the recent researchED Research Leads conference held in Cambridge, the 'ethics' of how school-based and led research should be conducted emerged as a key topic for discussion.   In this post I will explore some of the ethical issues associated with the role of the School Research Lead and school-based and led research. In doing so, I hope the post will generate, both discussion and debate amongst the burgeoning number of School Research Leads about the ethical challenges of conducting both school-based research and evidence-informed practice. This attempt to promote this much-need discussion is framed by the following questions.
  • What do we me mean by research? 
  • What are the implications for school-based research of conducting research within an ethical framework? 
  • What is the difference between research and evidence-informed practice? 
  • What are the ethical considerations which need to be considered when undertaking evidence-informed practice? 
What is meant by research?

This section draws upon the work of the National Research Ethics Service (NRES) and the National Patient Safety Agency guidelines: Defining Research. As such, research will be defined as the process of creating new generalisable knowledge, and which could include both the generation and testing of hypotheses. The NRES publication goes to state that research may involve some, it not all, of the following activities (amended for use in schools):
  • defined aims and objectives 
  • the testing or development of hypotheses 
  • comparing interventions 
  • collecting quantitative and qualitative data over and above data generally collected within the school - though could include normally collected data 
  • significant change to teaching approaches/support strategies - which are in addition to what is provided for pupils 
  • allocation of pupils to intervention groups 
  • the use of a sampling framework to decide who is within the study 
  • any form of intervention involving some form of randomnisation. 

What are the implications for school-based research of conducting research activities within an ethical framework?

  • There would appear to be a lack of understanding of the difference between research, quality improvement and evidence-based practice.
  • Much of the 'so-called' research or evidence-informed practice being undertaken in schools, could be classified as quality improvement
  • However, ethical considerations are just as relevant to quality improvement as to research
 However, it is unrealistic expect all changes to teacher's practice to be subject to ethical approval, and I now turn to the difference between research and evidence-informed practice.

What is the difference between research and evidence-informed practice?

In the context of nurse education, Carnwell (2001) identified the following differences between research and evidence-based practice. These differences are illustrated in Table 1, and have been amended for a school context.

Table 1 - The differences between research and evidence-based/informed practice










Amended from Carnwell (2001, p58)

As such, the main difference between research and evidence based practice is, evidence-based/informed practice is concerned with the USE of the best current available evidence to inform practice, taking into account the needs and wishes of the learner/pupils. Whereas research involves an attempt at the PRODUCTION/CREATION of new generalisable knowledge, which can be applied in a range of contexts.

What are the ethical issues associated with evidence-informed practice?

Accepting the distinction between research and evidence-based/informed practice, a number of ethical issues need to be addressed whilst engaging in evidence-informed practice. Again, I will turn to the evidence-based medicine movement for initial insight and the four principles which inform medical-ethics. In the following paragraphs the four principles of medical ethics are 'mapped' against a school setting.

Justice

The ‘justice’ principle requires the burdens and benefits of new teaching approaches or innovations to be distributed equally among all pupils or staff within the school. The ‘justice’ principle requires evidence-informed practice to uphold existing legislation, and to be fair to all pupils and staff.

Beneficence

This principle requires the action or intervention being proposed is being done with the intent of doing good for the pupil, member of staff or school.

Non-maleficence

This principle requires an action or intervention not to do harm to the pupil, member of staff involved or other stakeholders. Educators are required to take a wider perspective and consider whether actions may have unintended negative consequences, and which are subsequently experienced by others.

Autonomy 


This principle requires the pupil or member of staff have autonomy of thought and action when involved in decision-making. With pupils, and given the nature of teaching and learning it is difficult to imagine a situation with young children, where it is possible to envisage fully-informed consent in all circumstances. However, when projects involve other colleagues, this seeking their consent is both, principled and practical.

What are the implications of these principles for evidence-informed practice?

The implications of the above principles are .
  1. For teachers to ethically engage in evidence-informed practice they must be explicitly aware of an appropriate ethical framework. 
  2. Teachers to give active consideration to the application of that ethical framework prior to any changes in practice arising from an investigation of the best current available evidence. 
  3. Ethical considerations to be explicitly noted in some form; be it a note on a lesson plan; referenced to within a scheme work; or recorded in some way, be it a reflective diary or log. 
  4. Any processes for the recording of ethical issues need to be both, proportional and fit for purpose. 
To conclude:

In this post I have argued that the leadership and management of ethical issues is an integral part of the school research leads role. Second, if schools are to engage in research - as defined as seeking to create new and generalisable knowledge, including the testing or development of hypotheses - a clearly defined ethical approval process must be applied within the school. Third, evidence-informed practice involves making use of the best-available current evidence, and which distinguishes it from the prior definition of research. Fourth, teachers engaged in evidence-informed practice must be aware of ethical issues, and engage in a process of evidenced self-regulation. Fifth, whilst the enthusiasm for teachers to engage with research should welcomed and developed, it is essential colleagues use appropriate processes - this being a case of in order to do the right thing it is also essential to do things right. Sixth, whilst conceptual and operational clarity is being developed in relation to ethics, research and evidence-informed practice, teachers should focus on developing their skills as critical consumers of research. Finally, I hope this post is helpful in generating debates with schools about the ethical implications of conducting both research and evidence-informed practice.

Resources

Carnwell, R. (2001). Essential differences between research and evidence-based practice. Nurse Researcher8(2), 55-68.

https://www.bera.ac.uk/researchers-resources/publications/ethical-guidelines-for-educational-research-2011

http://www.lancashirecare.nhs.uk/media/Publications/R_and_D/Guidance/NRES_leaflet_Defining_Research.pdf

33 comments:

  1. Such great information. thanks for sharing this nice information with us.
    UK Coursework Help

    ReplyDelete
  2. A good and informative blog... indeed... I appreciate that you have shared such a good and informative blog with us....it’s very beneficial...Nursing Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great and informative post. thank you for sharing this information with us.
    Dissertation Writers UK

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hope now everyone could get Google play store cards easily. I saw many websites yesterday which are offering a complete guide in which we could read how to get google play gift card generator online. A complete free solution to get gift cards for Google play.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Custom Assignment Writing Services you acquire from Online College Assignment Help are of an unmatched standard that will definitely impress your professors when you present your Custom College Assignment Paper.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Conducting Evidence-Based School Cultures is most essential for giving proper awareness to the students towards their culture and traditions. I think teachers must give lessons to the students about Research Leads and Ethical Research in the school. Dissertation Writing Service



    ReplyDelete
  7. I love your content and the lessons you share with your readers. Every time I read a post, best forum I feel like I am able to take advantage of this post,

    ReplyDelete
  8. prescription computer glasses are designed to combine stylish looks with top-quality eye protection. Stay focused on the game with syghtglass latest gaming eyewear collection which block blue light micron anti-blue ray protection eye strain. Buy best frames prescription gaming glasses.

    * do gaming glasses work
    * anti blue ray glasses
    * Light up glasses

    ReplyDelete
  9. We are Professional academic custom assignment help service with a qualified of Subject Matter Experts who ensure you get the best assignments.

    ReplyDelete

  10. vBridge Hub is a Business Networking platform that connects Tech Vendors, Service Providers, Enterprises and Investors to accelerate the tech adoption process

    API Testing Software


    ReplyDelete

  11. “Faced with global competition and a growing focus on sustainability, companies looking to innovate faster or diversify their portfolios into new business areas need a new approach to develop, plan, build, operate and decommission projects differently,” said Thomas Grand, Vice President, Energy & Materials Industry, Dassault Systèmes. “Dassault Systèmes supports its renewable energy customers in their sustainable development. The 3DEXPERIENCE platform offers an inclusive, data-driven approach that enables real-time collaboration, improves execution and accelerates innovation. Companies like ReNew Power can deliver complex projects with transparency, accuracy and timeliness.”



    Renewable energy Articles

    ReplyDelete

  12. Various reason to pass time with hot and sexy girls, you must told that for fun, enjoyment and many more things but one things is common all in them you want to satisfaction and relax in your life. So KalyaniNagar escorts service have every type of girls who not only offer physical satisfaction but also you find chance to talk with educated and entertaining girls, our mostly model belong to good society and she is well cultured and know that how to behave with her lover so every time you find a girlfriend to hire Kalyani Nagar escorts.

    kalyani nagar call girls

    ReplyDelete

  13. Very easy way you select one of them who complete you wished and need. These all things are very simple and easy so if you are use any android phone them you contact with them an send mail but these all girls are offer escorts service for agency but taste of independent escorts service in Trivandrum is different because most of girls who offer

    escort service in Thiruvananthapuram
    escorts service they are want to earn money so they join escorts agency where they find customer and provide them sex enjoyment but when you talk about me then you find a different type of pleasure because I join independent escorts service not only for money but also I want to enjoy my life as I want where I find a lot of fun and enjoyment and spend time with different type of people who is fond love and pleasure.

    ReplyDelete

  14. It improves me feel than at some other time. The momentous opinions that I acknowledge with Pushkar Call Girls in cool are befuddling. Try to encounter pushkar call girls the warmth of the wonders by resting in their arms. It gives me gigantic joy and offers me a ton of delight. As there're such considerable assortments of individuals utilizing their hot administrations, utilizing notwithstanding can be required to be truly astounding to get shocking administrations.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Since you know about what a casual letter is, think about the Informal letter design. Composing an ideal casual letter will expect you to find out about the format of informal letter composing design too. We have shared instances of casual letters for your better agreement. To realize more on the best way to compose casual letters, keep perusing…

    ReplyDelete
  16. flats in Panvel

    Apartments and Flats in Panvel are offered by Ekadant Arealtors. You will receive up to Rs 18.5 Lacs in cashback each week and a half-off on stamp duty. Today you will be able to build your "Future Homes" in Panvel! The Marathon Nexzone offers the best of rural living to those looking for luxury condos in Panvel. With two and four bedroom homes and apartments available, Nexzone offers long distance racing enthusiasts in Panvel.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Solar Inverter dealer

    They offer solid activity and incredible execution and are profoundly talked about by its clients around the world. Benchmarks its prosperity on the achievement accomplished by its clients by recognizing and incorporating the most developed parts and methods accessible while offering an unrivaled get-togethers administration. In case you're searching for an inverter fix or sun based inverter provider that is responsive and comprehends the off-framework sun powered industry.

    ReplyDelete
  18. FEMA Consultants in Delhi

    India's foreign exchange environment has been liberalised with the introduction of FEMA in 1999. We strive to form strategies that capitalize on value across boundaries by taking a holistic approach. In order to create value for our clients, we aim to provide optimum solution. Global footprints are helping Indian companies to level up their impact and growth strategies, as a result of the focus on one world and one market. We offer quality services for Overseas Direct Investment (ODI) as a result of the laborious efforts needed to understand the regulatory framework & business risks.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Top Cockroaches Pest Control near Me

    Bugs are something beyond undesirable house visitors. Aside from an overall sensation of aversion they imbue and the unsafe microorganisms they acquaint with the climate, they can prompt long haul harm to the veneer, building designs, and dividers. In the event that a business or a working environment is experiencing nuisance invasion, the most dire outcome imaginable additionally incorporates shutting the business. It doesn't need to get that far, however. With Pest Control Care India, you can rapidly check the spread of any bug pervasion and check it before it can do any critical harm. We can uphold you with our long stretches of involvement with bug control.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Microsoft cloud service

    Purplish blue is Microsoft's large endeavor cloud, offered as a PaaS and IaaS administration. It is a well known help utilized by engineers who compose applications with the help of the organization's coding devices. Purplish blue offers the capacity to set aside cash, work quicker and coordinate information and on-premises applications in an incredible, versatile and adaptable way. This component filled help offers a half and half cloud arrangement, not at all like numerous other cloud suppliers that power clients to pick between the public cloud and their own server farms. Mixture cloud arrangements are known to offer more productivity and economy away, reinforcement and recuperation of information.

    ReplyDelete
  21. India Magazine

    India Today is an Indian week after week news magazine distributed by Living Media India Limited, in distribution since 1975 situated in New Delhi. India Today is likewise the name of its sister-distribution in Hindi. Today is important for the India bunch, additionally established in 1975, which presently incorporates 13 magazines, 3 radio broadcasts, 4 TV channels, 1 paper, an old style music name (Music Today), book distributing, and India's just book club. With the distribution of its 30th Anniversary issue in December 2005, the magazine, which had initiated distribution in 1975 with a dissemination of 5,000 duplicates, has distributed five releases and presently has a flow of over 1.1 million duplicates with a readership of over 5.62 million.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Best SEM & PPC Company in Mumbai

    PPC is a method of purchasing visits to your site by paying some measure of cash to an Advertising Platform. (Google, Bing, Yahoo) as opposed to endeavoring to "acquire" those visits naturally on web crawler. A promoting model that works with higher visits on your site, Pay Per Click administrations given by us at BrainCandy will assist you with delivering remarkable outcomes at altogether decreased expenses. PPC Ads are the most well known type of publicizing on the web and offer incredible returns and freedoms to fabricate your image. After carefully examining your plan of action and client base with regard for the smallest detail, we form procedures that are an ideal fit for your business to yield beneficial outcomes with most significant yields on speculation.

    ReplyDelete
  23. 360 Degree Camera System

    A 360-degree camera framework in a vehicle gives you a continuous perspective on the space encompassing your vehicle. The 360-degree camera tech consolidates the viewpoints of a few camcorders set around the vehicle into one picture, normally a hierarchical view. As you move into a parking spot, the 360-degree camera framework shows close by impediments, assisting you with keeping away from impacts. A higher perspective camera is essentially another term used to portray a 360-degree camera. Once in a while you'll likewise see 360-degree cameras alluded to as an encompass see camera, hierarchical camera, or around-see camera. They're various names for exactly the same thing: A camera framework that gives you a gander at what's around your vehicle.

    ReplyDelete
  24. prefabrication structure for commercial building

    In the event that you've done any starter research about steel building development, you have likely seen the expression "prefab" tossed around. To put it plainly, "prefab" is only a shortened form for "construction". At the point when a steel building is assigned "prefab", it implies that the underlying segments of the edge have been pre-designed, planned, cut, penetrated and painted before they send and convey for on location get together.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Health education is a social science that draws from the biological, environmental, psychological, physical and medical sciences to promote health and prevent disease, disability and premature death through education-driven voluntary behavior change activities.

    Read more blog:-

    How to Lose Weight with the Help of Lime?

    The Best way to Clean your Teeth at Home

    ReplyDelete
  26. In this blog, we will reveal to you the straightforward cycle to actuate direct store in your record. Be that as it may, before this, you need to know certain things. Money application direct store is a without charge administration of money application. Yet, in a few situations when clients decide to move the sum in a flash they need to pay extra charges for that. Saving the assets in a flash to the ledger is known as a moment store. Though an ordinary store cash application will require 3-5 days to store the assets to your connected ledger.

    cash app direct deposit
    cash app direct deposit
    cash app limit

    ReplyDelete
  27. Malerarbeiten in Österreich, Vorarlberg und Tirol. Der Maler für dekorative und exklusive Wandgestaltungen mit den besten Produkten von Rivedil, Novacolor, und Marmorino Tools. Hand gemachtes Kunstwerk auf die Wand. Spezialist für Renovation und Mieterwechsel bei Wohnungen, Bodenbeschichtung mit Epoxidharz. Fachmann für Schimmelsanierung und Entfeuchtung, Schimmeltelefon, Schimmel Notruf, Verleihung von Entfeuchtungsgeräten. Bauanschlussfugen auf auf Baustellen, Wartungsarbeiten bei Silikon Fugen in Bädern.

    Maler in Vorarlberg
    Schimmel Entfernung

    ReplyDelete
  28. Cash App direct deposit Help Service Now Accessible From The Home Like Comfort
    It is safe to say that you are one of those clients who battling because of various issues relating to cash app deposit? Get the right sort of Help for cash app direct deposit under by our expert, in a matter of seconds.

    ReplyDelete
  29. eAstroHelp is India's leading website for Astrology-based resources. The Company aims at promoting ancient occult science from India across the globe. cancer rising appearance

    ReplyDelete
  30. We work as a lead generator for various travel agencies. We only provide recent updates about various airline policies and features. We do not have any association with any airlines. Our business is to work as a mediator between travel agents and travel agencies.
    https://airlinesreservationsdeals.com/airport-codes/

    ReplyDelete
  31. These are the steps to follow to enable Cash App direct deposit on your phone if you are a verified Cash App user.

    ReplyDelete